| [Poll] LNOE or ATOE | |
|
+4Ellesar deadwood rbayu2 melchior28 8 posters |
|
Last Night on Earth or A Touch of Evil | Last Night on Earth | | 20% | [ 1 ] | A Touch of Evil | | 80% | [ 4 ] |
| Total Suara : 5 | | |
|
Pengirim | Message |
---|
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Sun Aug 31, 2008 2:03 am | |
| Frens. Aku lagi bingung nih. So here we are.
Aku tau ATOE blon kluar, tapi kalo kita baca review2 dari org2 yg ke GenCon taun ini: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/334468 http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/322986 http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/333674
bisa kira2 menebak gimana kalo 2 game ini dijejerin.
LNOE full coop game dengan banyak scenario dan zombies. Udah keluar sejak taon lalu dan bisa dicek rulebooknya. ATOE: Dari yg kubaca, AH-Lite... And for me, that's like a dream come true.
Gua cuman punya budget utk 1 horor game. What do you think? | |
|
| |
rbayu2 Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1263 Age : 50 Lokasi : Jakarta Kerjaan : Selling cotton Serius Gaming : August 2006 Registration date : 09.01.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Sun Aug 31, 2008 7:45 pm | |
| gua lom pernah maen dua2nya tapi voting gua berdasarkan dari baca2 tentang dua game tersebut, dan gua putuskan kayaknya temanya lebih menarik ATOE. | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Sun Aug 31, 2008 9:26 pm | |
| Duh... Gua rencananya ke PI di singapura untuk nyari nih. Kalo ada ATOE gua pingin banget beli, cuman keliatannya kesempatan ngedapetin game ini tipis banget deh. Di US aja blon kluar. Kabarnya Sept. tp yah biasa bakal ngaret. | |
|
| |
deadwood Geek Counselor
Jumlah posting : 2716 Age : 40 Lokasi : Binus, JakBar Kerjaan : Part Time BoardGamer Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 25.03.08
| |
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Sun Aug 31, 2008 11:11 pm | |
| | |
|
| |
Ellesar Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 397 Age : 38 Lokasi : Jakarta Kerjaan : IT Auditor / Consultant Serius Gaming : Hybrid Wargames Registration date : 01.06.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Sun Aug 31, 2008 11:17 pm | |
| Pendapat gw aja sih, rasanya ATOE lebih menarik. Mungkin karena gw subyektif kurang suka game zombie aja kali ya.. Zombies are to be shot in FPS games, not boardgames for me.. | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 12:58 am | |
| Ada yg ingin comment tentang gameplay? Gua rasa themenya sama bagus deh. | |
|
| |
kin2x Geek Enthusiast
Jumlah posting : 837 Age : 43 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : cook Serius Gaming : starting already Registration date : 03.06.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 1:14 am | |
| - melchior28 wrote:
- Ada yg ingin comment tentang gameplay? Gua rasa themenya sama bagus deh.
loe bisa baca di forum kita di bedah game gue udah jelasin rulenya sejelas mungkin dlm bhs indo sama loe bisa liat di session report yg secret affair juga ada exclusive report yg gue buat ber2 sama agus juga.... | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 9:13 am | |
| Session reportnya keren banget bro! Cuman gua ada yg bingung nih. Yg pegang dinamit apa perlu mengorbankan diri gitu. Apa ga bisa dilempar? | |
|
| |
fenderman Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1150 Age : 43 Lokasi : West Jakarta Kerjaan : Musician Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 10.05.08
| |
| |
kin2x Geek Enthusiast
Jumlah posting : 837 Age : 43 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : cook Serius Gaming : starting already Registration date : 03.06.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 1:52 pm | |
| - fenderman wrote:
- melchior28 wrote:
- Session reportnya keren banget bro!
Cuman gua ada yg bingung nih. Yg pegang dinamit apa perlu mengorbankan diri gitu. Apa ga bisa dilempar? bisa aj sih sebenarnya...cuma kalo dy lempar gak sempet kalo diitung dengan moves nya dll, apalagi zombienya banyaknya minta ampun (kebetulan gw yang pegang zombie), so terpaksa dy bunuh diri, biar kena smw. itu taktik gila... setau gue bukan dinamit yg dipake buat ledakin tapi dia pake bensin+korek buat bakar zombie2 n dianya ndiri....kalo dinamit mah udahpasti di lempar donk ah... gue sebagai otak dari taktik gila ini hehehe...untung partner gue kooperatif bgt ga ada yg autis jadi mission complete...... game lnoe maen scenario mana aja kalo menurut gue bakal deg2an loenya soalnya tiap scenario memberikan nuansa yg berbeda2.....n seru pastinya...gue ga pernah nyesel beli ini game.... kalo ATOE gue blm pernah liat,tapi seperti yg gue bilang diatas begitu keluar pasti bakalan gue libas ini game.... | |
|
| |
fenderman Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1150 Age : 43 Lokasi : West Jakarta Kerjaan : Musician Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 10.05.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 2:21 pm | |
| | |
|
| |
Darkmot Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 364 Age : 42 Lokasi : Surabaya Kerjaan : Gaming Registration date : 21.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 3:58 pm | |
| Wah, temanya beda jauh tuh. Arkham Horror temanya mitos Cthulhu, kalo ATOE temanya Nocturnal Creatures, LNOE temanya Zombies.
Overall, aku sendiri secara tema lebih suka ATOE. Kalo gameplay, mungkin semuanya pada inovatif aku kira. Sebaiknya, daripada masalah gameplay, mending liat masalah replayability Wan. Antara ATOE dan LNOE replayabilitynya kira2 bakal lebih besar mana bagi kamu? | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 4:19 pm | |
| - Darkmot wrote:
- Wah, temanya beda jauh tuh. Arkham Horror temanya mitos Cthulhu, kalo ATOE temanya Nocturnal Creatures, LNOE temanya Zombies.
Overall, aku sendiri secara tema lebih suka ATOE. Kalo gameplay, mungkin semuanya pada inovatif aku kira. Sebaiknya, daripada masalah gameplay, mending liat masalah replayability Wan. Antara ATOE dan LNOE replayabilitynya kira2 bakal lebih besar mana bagi kamu? Maksudnya ATOE tuh "Gameplay"nya yg mirip. Alias lawan bos. Emang ATOE sering dibandingin sama AH. Gua rasa soal replayability sih... mirip. LNOE mapnya variable dan ada banyak scenario. ATOE banyak kartu dan Eldernya juga beda, plus final bos nya macem macem. Jadi IMHO, replayabilitynya sama. | |
|
| |
deadwood Geek Counselor
Jumlah posting : 2716 Age : 40 Lokasi : Binus, JakBar Kerjaan : Part Time BoardGamer Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 25.03.08
| |
| |
fenderman Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1150 Age : 43 Lokasi : West Jakarta Kerjaan : Musician Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 10.05.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 4:25 pm | |
| - melchior28 wrote:
Maksudnya ATOE tuh "Gameplay"nya yg mirip. Alias lawan bos. Emang ATOE sering dibandingin sama AH.
hehe maap salah ketik, gameplay maksud gw....tema sih beda | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 4:26 pm | |
| Gampang~~ Kan ada 3L. Huehehehehe~ | |
|
| |
deadwood Geek Counselor
Jumlah posting : 2716 Age : 40 Lokasi : Binus, JakBar Kerjaan : Part Time BoardGamer Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 25.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 4:32 pm | |
| | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 5:59 pm | |
| Keliatannya ATOE tuh..... hmmm... mirip AH in the sense too many things to keep track of. Mungkin kalo udah maen opini gua bakal brubah... But for now, gua rasa gua akan ambil LNOE. Simpler and butchier. Hehehe... Thanks anyways guys.
Kalo ada yg udah beli ATOE, tell me all abt it. | |
|
| |
kin2x Geek Enthusiast
Jumlah posting : 837 Age : 43 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : cook Serius Gaming : starting already Registration date : 03.06.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 6:34 pm | |
| - melchior28 wrote:
- Keliatannya ATOE tuh..... hmmm... mirip AH in the sense too many things to keep track of.
Mungkin kalo udah maen opini gua bakal brubah... But for now, gua rasa gua akan ambil LNOE. Simpler and butchier. Hehehe... Thanks anyways guys.
Kalo ada yg udah beli ATOE, tell me all abt it. tenang aja bro kalo gue udah beli ATOE pasti abis nyoba bakal gue buat review spt LNOE juga koq | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 6:43 pm | |
| - kin2x wrote:
- melchior28 wrote:
- Keliatannya ATOE tuh..... hmmm... mirip AH in the sense too many things to keep track of.
Mungkin kalo udah maen opini gua bakal brubah... But for now, gua rasa gua akan ambil LNOE. Simpler and butchier. Hehehe... Thanks anyways guys.
Kalo ada yg udah beli ATOE, tell me all abt it.
tenang aja bro kalo gue udah beli ATOE pasti abis nyoba bakal gue buat review spt LNOE juga koq Sipz! Ntar kalo gue tergoda, loe beli LNOE gue yah. Hehehehehe~ | |
|
| |
kin2x Geek Enthusiast
Jumlah posting : 837 Age : 43 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : cook Serius Gaming : starting already Registration date : 03.06.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 6:46 pm | |
| bro gue itu owner LNOE buat apa beli lagi nih,paling kalo loe ke spore gue titip beli yg expannya growing hunger hehehe......kalo penasaran mo coba yah ayo jumat ini dtg jkt ke 2c gue bakal gelar lnoe ini........ | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 9:09 pm | |
| Yah siapa tau mau extra. Satu dikoleksi satu dimaenin.
Growing hunger mahal ga sih? Nambahin apa aja? | |
|
| |
fenderman Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1150 Age : 43 Lokasi : West Jakarta Kerjaan : Musician Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 10.05.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 9:24 pm | |
| Nambah 3 scenario, 4 hero baru, 7 red zombies (zombie yang bawa plague gt). Trus nambah board baru. Trus kalo gak salah nambah kartu zombie, jadi zombienya bisa curi senjata heroes. | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE Mon Sep 01, 2008 9:31 pm | |
| Tapi mahal banget amit2! Base game $50, expansion koq bisa $40. Nambah banyak juga ngga... | |
|
| |
Sponsored content
| Subyek: Re: [Poll] LNOE or ATOE | |
| |
|
| |
| [Poll] LNOE or ATOE | |
|