| which one is better | |
|
+5kohee melchior28 deadwood RobinHood_01 astray 9 posters |
Pengirim | Message |
---|
astray Geek Converted
Jumlah posting : 244 Age : 44 Lokasi : Surabaya Kerjaan : Designer, Gamer Serius Gaming : 2005 Registration date : 16.01.08
| Subyek: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 1:52 pm | |
| everybody!!!!!i need help ada yg bisa kasi komentar buat boardgame2 berikut????biar yakin mana yg mo dbeli g nyari yg replayability tinggi n complexity ckp tinggi Large Box : - War of The Ring - Twilight Imperium 3 - Starcraft - Descent Medium Box : - A Games of Throne - Arkham Horror - Fury of Dracula - Blue Moon City komennya plz........ | |
|
| |
RobinHood_01 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 277 Lokasi : Jakarta Registration date : 09.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 1:59 pm | |
| large box nya mah ok-ok semua tuh...so...dibeli semua laaahhhh, hehehehehe | |
|
| |
deadwood Geek Counselor
Jumlah posting : 2716 Age : 40 Lokasi : Binus, JakBar Kerjaan : Part Time BoardGamer Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 25.03.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 2:01 pm | |
| itu sih game bagus semua ... tinggal mo nyari playtime`nya aja mau yg brp lama ... | |
|
| |
melchior28 Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 459 Lokasi : Surabaya Registration date : 24.03.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 2:03 pm | |
| Large Box:
War of the Ring: Ga beli WOTR ga bisa dibilang boardgamer sejati. Period. Twilight Imperium 3: Kalo kuat bayar, cari org buat maen dan angkat, silahkan. Hehehe. Starcraft: I would buy the PC version.... Sorry... Descent: Uhuk uhuk.... Wotr! Uhuk...
Medium Box:
Game of Thrones: Blum pernah maen. No comment. Looks good though... Arkham Horror: Medium? Fury of Dracula: Mending Arkham Blue Moon City: Knizia. 'Nuff said. | |
|
| |
kohee Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1208 Age : 40 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : Technical Consultant Serius Gaming : January 2007 Registration date : 08.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 5:27 pm | |
| large box:
TI3 sama WOTR adalah kewajiban....
starcraft lom bisa ngalahin keindahan TI3...sori.... descent? well I dont like this game, mekaniknya lebih cocok buat DOOM daripada setting RPG...besides, ga ada yg bisa ngalahin warhammer quest kalo soal dungeon exploring...
medium box:
AGOT (skip) = bagus banget...tapi sebenernya ini game predecessor nya starcraft, mekanik order token nya starcraft diambil dari sini. dan dari awal game penempatan posisi nya gak balance. kalo mau yg kaya gini nunggu bentar aja ada game bakal keluar namanya SENJI, mirip2 gini tapi setting nya medieval jepang (bahkan mo dibikin versi dunianya Legend of 5 rings)
Fury of dracula (skip)
BMC hehe ini masuk wishlist gw...bagus fast paced, komponen indah, seru juga
Arkham Horror --> MUST BUY NUFF SAID !!!! | |
|
| |
indofungames Geek Enthusiast
Jumlah posting : 954 Age : 47 Lokasi : Batam Kerjaan : Test Engineer Serius Gaming : 2002 Registration date : 07.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 5:40 pm | |
| busyettt ... semua 8 game yang di sebut, belon ada yang gw perna maeinin ... sorry bro, can't help u this time | |
|
| |
deadwood Geek Counselor
Jumlah posting : 2716 Age : 40 Lokasi : Binus, JakBar Kerjaan : Part Time BoardGamer Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 25.03.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 5:51 pm | |
| | |
|
| |
kohee Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1208 Age : 40 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : Technical Consultant Serius Gaming : January 2007 Registration date : 08.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 6:01 pm | |
| little k sekolahin di jkt aja...jadi bisa diajak ke jalur wargame sama koko dani & koko vidor...kita ajak maen counter wargames YAYAYAYAY tar dia pulang ke batam langsung tereak2: 'PAPA, NAY TO EURO !!' 'WARGAMES ARE IN THE HOUSE YO' | |
|
| |
cottonkid Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 341 Age : 37 Lokasi : Jakarta & Bandung Kerjaan : Carcassonne Addict Serius Gaming : Februari 2008 Registration date : 15.02.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Mon Jun 09, 2008 9:16 pm | |
| WOTR kayanya highly recommended tuh sama smua orang. termasuk gw sndiri jd beli ni gara2 kena racun. yg mo bantu soal rule nya yg ribet juga banyak, jd complex rule is no problem bro. Plus nya lg dr wotr, this is a game for 2 players. game ribet pasti susah nyari orang buat maen. jadi tinggal cari 1 orang sesama gamer, bisa langsung main deh | |
|
| |
Darkmot Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 364 Age : 42 Lokasi : Surabaya Kerjaan : Gaming Registration date : 21.03.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Tue Jun 10, 2008 8:51 am | |
| Untuk Fury of Dracula dan Blue Moon City, bisa diliat di http://www.boardgameswithscott.com/, cari aja video reviewnya, penjelasannya sangat lengkap. Tapi kalo mediummu seperti itu, mending Arkham Horror deh.
Kalo big boxnya, dan kriteriamu replayability, rasanya mending TI3 deh, walaupun aku belon pernah maen. WoTR rasanya bagus, tapi apa replayabilitynya tinggi, itu yang agak ngga yakin. | |
|
| |
kohee Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1208 Age : 40 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : Technical Consultant Serius Gaming : January 2007 Registration date : 08.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Tue Jun 10, 2008 9:47 am | |
| WOTR bagus banget, cuma setup awalnya selalu sama
kalo TI3 beda2, apalagi sistemnya pake modular board cuma TI3 playtime nya cukup lama hehehe | |
|
| |
deadwood Geek Counselor
Jumlah posting : 2716 Age : 40 Lokasi : Binus, JakBar Kerjaan : Part Time BoardGamer Serius Gaming : April 2008 Registration date : 25.03.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Tue Jun 10, 2008 10:37 am | |
| game2 begitu sih kayanya kendala salah satu ada di kesulitan dalam mengumpulkan playernya... yg gampang cari playernya sih paling blue moon city ... wotr mayan gampang rasanya karena cuma perlu cari 1 orang lain lg untuk maen`nya .. | |
|
| |
astray Geek Converted
Jumlah posting : 244 Age : 44 Lokasi : Surabaya Kerjaan : Designer, Gamer Serius Gaming : 2005 Registration date : 16.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Tue Jun 10, 2008 12:30 pm | |
| waduh!!!racunnya byk bgt...malah bingung hahahahahaha utk sementara large box msh bingung antara TI3 ( gameplay bgs ) ma starcraft ( theme yg tak suka ) hehehehe klo medium box dah pesen AH dr sat u,kueren bgt d game ini!!!! hr minggu wkt test play d toy fair GM meskipun ckp byk yg msh bingung,tp basicnya dah tau, emg bener minta darkmot bw in game nya BMC menyusul d...... thx buat semua serangan racunnya hrs cpt2 nyari antidote neh | |
|
| |
kohee Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1208 Age : 40 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : Technical Consultant Serius Gaming : January 2007 Registration date : 08.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Tue Jun 10, 2008 1:24 pm | |
| mending sih TI3 aja....masih diatas Starcraft.
btw starcraft disini gak kaya PC nya dimana kita kontrol pasukan banyak vs banyak disini lebih kaya skirmish, paling2 dalam 1 battle cuma ada 6-10 pasukan adu jotos...
dan walaupun dituntut buat maen agresif, selama gw maen bbrp kali sih biasanya mrk2 yg dah secure source buat VP, langsung pada pasif sambil nungguin end game...
kalo TI3 objective2nya biasanya sulit2. dan 1 turn kita dibatesin cuma bisa selesain 1 objective...jadi walaupun kita sanggup selesain 4 objective sekaligus, kita butuh 4 full turn baru bisa selesain 4 4 nya. lagian ada secret objective yg bikin serunya...yg kadang2 ga bisa kita duga. 1 lg di TI3 ada political phase yg mnrt gw keren banget trus bisa sogok menyogok, trade treaty dll....keren abis | |
|
| |
astray Geek Converted
Jumlah posting : 244 Age : 44 Lokasi : Surabaya Kerjaan : Designer, Gamer Serius Gaming : 2005 Registration date : 16.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Tue Jun 10, 2008 7:04 pm | |
| woooooo thx infonya....... g ga sempat nyoba starcraft wkt d toy fair, apa obj tiap leader cmn yg d boardnya aja???selain itu apa ga ada obj laen???
hmm....TI3 kok keren bgt kliatannya......klo liat ranking emg lbh keren TI3 sih...jauuuuuuh d atas starcraft!!!! ok2....tak baca2 rulenya dl..... btw...dah nyoba smua nya ya??? wah d sby ada yg punya starcraft ato TI3 ga neh???? | |
|
| |
Darkmot Geek Adept
Jumlah posting : 364 Age : 42 Lokasi : Surabaya Kerjaan : Gaming Registration date : 21.03.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Wed Jun 11, 2008 8:17 am | |
| - astray wrote:
- woooooo thx infonya.......
g ga sempat nyoba starcraft wkt d toy fair, apa obj tiap leader cmn yg d boardnya aja???selain itu apa ga ada obj laen???
hmm....TI3 kok keren bgt kliatannya......klo liat ranking emg lbh keren TI3 sih...jauuuuuuh d atas starcraft!!!! ok2....tak baca2 rulenya dl..... btw...dah nyoba smua nya ya??? wah d sby ada yg punya starcraft ato TI3 ga neh???? Yang punya starcraft ada tuh. Sinyo2 kecil yg beli . Hadooh, mana ngerti mereka maennya. Paling miniaturnya ditabrak2in gitu . Btw untuk starcraft, untuk win the game ada 2 kondisi, 1 siapa yg paling cepat mencapai titik terakhir dari VP track, ato yg memenuhi kondisi masing2 dari leader yg dipilih. | |
|
| |
kohee Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1208 Age : 40 Lokasi : jakarta Kerjaan : Technical Consultant Serius Gaming : January 2007 Registration date : 08.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Wed Jun 11, 2008 11:52 am | |
| starcraft emang objective nya dah keliatan di player board masing2...dan kayaknya ga begitu balance sih, ada yg gampang banget kaya arcturus mengsk. nah kalo TI3 ini objective pribadi masing2 tuh secret hehehe jadi ga balance pun kalo kita pinter maen nya bisa dicapai.
kalo soal sampe max vp sama sih, TI sampe 10 VP, cuma lama sampenya hehe
bagusnya TI support bbrp varian rules yg bisa kita pake, misal varian distant sun, dimana tiap planet yg kita explore punya event masing2, atau kita bisa pake hero, jadi tiap race punya hero2 yg jenisnya macem2 misal politikus atau tactician, trus kita bisa nyandera hero lawan juga hehehe | |
|
| |
rbayu2 Geek Veteran
Jumlah posting : 1263 Age : 50 Lokasi : Jakarta Kerjaan : Selling cotton Serius Gaming : August 2006 Registration date : 09.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Wed Jun 11, 2008 11:55 am | |
| Gua udah nyobain dua2nya TI3 ama starcraft...kayaknya memang lebih bagus TI3 sih...walaupun maennya lebih lama... | |
|
| |
astray Geek Converted
Jumlah posting : 244 Age : 44 Lokasi : Surabaya Kerjaan : Designer, Gamer Serius Gaming : 2005 Registration date : 16.01.08
| Subyek: Re: which one is better Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:15 am | |
| hohohohohohohohoho dah mo order TI3 neh...cmn ga tau dana e dr mana hehehehehe | |
|
| |
Sponsored content
| Subyek: Re: which one is better | |
| |
|
| |
| which one is better | |
|